Smart speaker vs ceiling speakers: which one for a DIY smart home
Three routes: a smart speaker on a shelf, a streaming amplifier with passive ceiling speakers, or a ready-made system. Here is who each suits, what to buy and what to skip.
- No renovation and you want it today: a smart speaker on a shelf (Amazon Echo or Apple HomePod) is plug and play.
- Renovation ahead and music in every room: streaming amplifier plus passive ceiling speakers, with cables run before finishing.
- A voice assistant adds to wall switches and scenes, it does not replace them; pick a device with a physical mic switch and verify it in the model's specs.
- No speaker without a stated IP rating in a bathroom, and never leave cable for later: it cannot be pulled after finishing.
The short answer: three routes
Sound quality does not decide this; your situation does: are the walls still open, how many rooms need sound, do you want voice control.
- Smart speaker on a shelf — Amazon Echo Dot 5, Echo Pop, Echo Show 8 or Apple HomePod 3rd gen. No cable runs or installation; right for a flat with no renovation planned.
- Streaming amplifier + passive ceiling speakers — the catalogue has streaming amplifiers (Ekinex EK-30S-AU, EK-50S-AU) and passive built-in speakers (Basalte Cielo C6, Loxone Install Speaker 7 Passive, Ekinex EK-Q15CG-BI). They are not a matched kit: pair amplifier and speakers by impedance (ohms) and power in the datasheets. Only a grille shows, but cables go in before finishing.
- Ready-made system — Loxone Wireless Speaker (per the manufacturer, no wiring and no Audioserver), a Loxone Audioserver with passive Install Speakers, or Master/Client speakers on a Loxone Miniserver; Ekinex Sentio streamers, linked to KNX by the KNX-Sentio Gateway.
If in doubt, start with the first route, but run a spare cable while the ceiling is open: far easier than opening it later.
Comparison: what you need, pros and cons
| Route | What you need | Pros / cons | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Smart speaker (Echo, HomePod) | Socket, Wi-Fi, account and app | + no installation, built-in assistant; − one room, sound from one point; check per model where voice is processed | Flat without renovation, kitchen, bedroom |
| Amplifier + passive ceiling speakers | Streaming amplifier, speakers, a cable per speaker, ceiling cut-outs | + even coverage, only a grille shows; − cables before finishing; match amplifier and speakers by ohms and power | Renovation or new build, music throughout |
| Ready-made system (Loxone, Ekinex Sentio) | Loxone: Audioserver or Master/Client speakers; Ekinex: Sentio streamer and speakers | + Loxone speakers also play doorbell, announcements and alarms; Sentio is controlled from KNX via the gateway; − more parts and setup | You already run Loxone or KNX and want integration |
Vendor figures: Loxone suggests one speaker per 15 m² in living spaces with a standard ceiling height; the Audioserver has 4 speaker outputs and supports AirPlay 2 from firmware 2.5.01.11.
Voice assistant and privacy
Voice is handy for scenes and music but must never be the only control: the wall switch must work without internet. An always-on microphone is a privacy question: check for a physical mic switch and whether speech is recognised on the device or in the cloud.
- Home Assistant Voice Preview Edition: 2 microphones, a physical switch that cuts their power, wake word detected on the device. Whether speech stays local depends on the engine you choose: Speech-to-Phrase (local, preset phrases only), Whisper (local, Intel N100-class computer recommended) or Home Assistant Cloud. Language support is a work in progress; the built-in speaker is not optimised for music.
- Loxone: the manufacturer confirms only Apple HomeKit and Siri; Alexa or Google Assistant support is not confirmed. Loxone text-to-speech needs an internet connection.
- Ekinex delégo: voice only through Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant, via the Ekinex cloud.
DIY ceiling speakers: what to prepare during renovation
Anything you cannot add later is done before plasterboard and filler. Fitting a speaker is easy; the cable is the hard part.
- Draw a plan: which rooms get music, and where the amplifier lives (cabinet, distribution board or utility room).
- Run a separate cable from each speaker to the amplifier. For its own amplifiers Loxone specifies 4–8 ohm passive speakers and cable up to 2.5 mm²; otherwise check the amplifier's datasheet.
- Leave slack: about 0.5–1 m of cable at each speaker (a practical guide, not a standard), and cable the rooms you may add later.
- Pick the mounting: a mounting frame in plasterboard (for example Ekinex EK-Q15CG-BOX for the Q15CG speaker), a cast-in housing in concrete, a backbox in a suspended ceiling; Loxone has these for the 7 and 10 inch Install Speaker.
- Check dimensions: the Loxone Install Speaker 7 needs a 200–210 mm cut-out and 93 mm depth; its magnetic grille can be painted.
In an apartment building ask your designer whether the ceiling needs a fire hood: per Monitor Audio, an in-ceiling speaker is not fire-rated on its own.
What not to do
- No speaker without an IP rating in a bathroom. Makers state it: Loxone Install Speaker 7 and 10 are IP53/54, Satellite Speaker IP64, the Ekinex on-wall pair IP66. Confirm your bathroom zone with the manufacturer and your electrician.
- Do not leave the cable for after finishing. Then only wireless speakers or opening the ceiling remain.
- Do not cover a big room with one speaker. Loxone's one per 15 m² is a starting point; a large living room needs a pair or more.
- Do not buy amplifier and speakers by guesswork. Compare impedance (ohms) and power in the datasheets first.
The full range is under speakers and amplifiers.
Frequently asked questions
Smart speaker or ceiling speakers: which is better for a smart home?
A smart speaker is quicker and simpler for one room. Ceiling speakers with an amplifier give even sound across the house, but need cables laid during renovation.
Is a smart speaker always listening?
A smart speaker waits for its wake word, so the microphone stays on. Pick a device with a physical mic switch and check in the model's specs where speech is recognised. On the Home Assistant Voice PE the switch cuts power to the mics and the wake word is detected on the device.
How many ceiling speakers does a room need?
Loxone recommends one speaker per 15 m² in living spaces with a standard ceiling height; use a pair for stereo.
Can I install ceiling speakers after renovation?
Yes, if the cable is already in place. Without it you have to open the ceiling, so run cables before finishing.
Does Loxone work with Alexa or Google Assistant?
Not officially: Loxone confirms only Apple HomeKit and Siri. Alexa and Google Assistant support is not confirmed, and its Matter integration is experimental, without technical support.
Speakers and amplifiers
Ekinex, Loxone and Basalte speakers, streamers and amplifiers in the catalogue.